Sarkari RiseLogin

Weather Modification / Cloud Seeding — UPSC Mains Model Answer

Environment · UPSC CSE
Question: Environmental concerns and governance challenges of large-scale cloud seeding operations

Introduction

Cloud seeding, increasingly deployed for drought mitigation and hail suppression, raises legitimate environmental questions that extend well beyond the target precipitation zone, demanding rigorous scientific scrutiny and regulatory oversight.

Body

1. Transboundary Precipitation Disruption

Large-scale seeding can enhance rainfall over target areas while reducing moisture available to downwind regions, effectively redistributing a shared atmospheric resource. This creates potential for inter-state and international disputes, as one jurisdiction's water gain may be another's deficit. The World Meteorological Organization has flagged the absence of binding international protocols governing such interventions.

2. Silver Iodide Accumulation in Ecosystems

Silver iodide, the most widely used seeding agent, is toxic to aquatic microorganisms at elevated concentrations. Repeated operations over watersheds risk gradual bioaccumulation in soil, sediment, and water bodies, potentially disrupting microbial communities that underpin nutrient cycling. Field studies from regions with sustained seeding programmes have detected measurable silver concentrations in downstream catchments.

3. Stratospheric Ozone — A Misattributed Concern

Cloud seeding agents are dispersed in the troposphere, well below the stratosphere where ozone depletion occurs. Attributing ozone damage to conventional seeding chemicals lacks scientific basis; this concern conflates cloud seeding with stratospheric aerosol injection, a distinct and experimental geoengineering approach.

4. Governance and Regulatory Gaps

India's weather modification activities lack a dedicated statutory framework, leaving environmental impact assessment largely discretionary. A centralised regulatory body with mandatory pre-operation modelling, post-operation monitoring, and cross-border notification protocols is essential before scaling operations.

Conclusion

Concerns one and two represent scientifically grounded risks warranting precautionary regulation; concern three conflates distinct technologies. Effective governance must separate evidence-based risks from misconceptions to enable responsible, equitable use of weather modification.

Word count: 242

Get your own answer evaluated by AI

GS Answer Coach grades your Mains answer on structure, substance, and conclusion — in under a minute.

Open GS Answer CoachPractice Weather Modification / Cloud Seeding PYQs →

Related PYQs on Weather Modification / Cloud Seeding

PYQ 2025
Which of the following are used in cloud seeding for artificial rainfall to reduce air pollution?
PYQ
The first successful scientific experiment of artificial rainmaking using dry ice was conducted in which year?
PYQ
The technique of 'glaciogenic seeding' in cloud seeding primarily targets which type of clouds?
PYQ
The technique of 'hygroscopic seeding' used in warm cloud seeding primarily relies on which substance?
PYQ
Project STORM (Systematic Tropical Ocean-atmosphere Research and Monsoon), sometimes discussed in the context of weather modification in India, is associated with which organisation?

More Environment model answers

Agriculture
Air Pollution / SO2 Emissions
Biodiversity
Biodiversity / Endemic Species
Biodiversity / Insects
Biodiversity Conservation

Daily AI coaching for UPSC Mains

Essay Coach · GS Answer Coach · Cutoff Planner · 500+ Mains PYQs — free to sign up.

Sign up freeSee UPSC Pro