Sarkari RiseLogin

Finance Commission / 15th FC Recommendations — UPSC Mains Model Answer

Polity · UPSC CSE
Question: Significance and key recommendations of the 15th Finance Commission and their implications for fiscal federalism in India

Introduction

The 15th Finance Commission, constituted under Article 280, submitted its report covering 2021-26, reshaping Centre-State fiscal relations at a time of post-pandemic economic stress and evolving cooperative federalism demands.

Body

1. Vertical Devolution: Tax Share to States

The 15th FC recommended that 41% of the net proceeds of divisible Union taxes be devolved to States, a marginal reduction from the 14th FC's 42%, primarily to accommodate the newly formed Union Territories of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh. This vertical share remains the foundational pillar of fiscal transfers.

2. Horizontal Distribution Criteria

The Commission introduced demographic performance as a criterion, rewarding States that managed population growth effectively. It also retained income distance and area-based criteria, while reintroducing tax effort to incentivise States' own revenue mobilisation — a significant shift toward performance-linked federalism.

3. Sector-Specific Grants

Grants were recommended for health, education, and local bodies with performance conditions attached. Education-linked grants aimed at improving learning outcomes were included, though the precise allocation was tied to measurable indicators rather than unconditional transfers, nudging States toward outcome-based governance.

4. Agriculture and Fiscal Reforms Incentives

The Commission recommended performance-based incentives linked to agricultural sector reforms, including market liberalisation and land-lease reforms, though actual uptake by States remained limited given political sensitivities around farm legislation.

Conclusion

The 15th FC's architecture balances equity with efficiency by linking grants to outcomes and rewarding fiscal discipline. Sustained implementation depends on States' administrative capacity and Centre-State trust, both of which remain works in progress.

Word count: 222

Get your own answer evaluated by AI

GS Answer Coach grades your Mains answer on structure, substance, and conclusion — in under a minute.

Open GS Answer CoachPractice Finance Commission / 15th FC Recommendations PYQs →

Related PYQs on Finance Commission / 15th FC Recommendations

PYQ
The 15th Finance Commission recommended that the share of states in the net proceeds of the divisible pool of central taxes should be fixed at which percentage for the period 2021-26?
PYQ
Consider the following criteria used by the 15th Finance Commission for horizontal devolution among states: 1. Population (2011 Census) 2. Area 3. Forest and Ecology 4. Income Distance 5. Demographic Performance 6. Tax Effort Which of the following correctly states the weight assigned to 'Demographic Performance' criterion?
PYQ
The 15th Finance Commission recommended a 'Basic Grant' and 'Performance Grant' split for urban local bodies. What was the ratio of Basic to Performance Grant recommended?
PYQ
What percentage of the net proceeds of the Union taxes did the 15th Finance Commission recommend to be devolved to the States for the period 2021-26?
PYQ
The 15th Finance Commission used which of the following criteria with the highest weight for horizontal devolution (inter-se distribution) among States?

More Polity model answers

Awards / Gandhi Peace Prize
BIMSTEC / Regional Cooperation
Constituent Assembly
Constitution
Constitution / Eighth Schedule & Amendments
Constitution / Parts of the Constitution

Daily AI coaching for UPSC Mains

Essay Coach · GS Answer Coach · Cutoff Planner · 500+ Mains PYQs — free to sign up.

Sign up freeSee UPSC Pro